Welcome‎ > ‎

Essay: The Tin Man and His Tin Scissors

Last year, I described our Governor, the often-less-than-affable-but-always-smart Jerry Brown, as exhibiting the "empty kettle" syndrome fictionally attributed to the Tin Man in Oz: echoing chest, sans heart.  When cuts needed to be made due to rising deficits, again and again the Governor slashed the safety net programs that keep our poorest families alive and almost well.  In 2012, K-12 education monies were also threatened with evisceration--a threat that was avoided in the current budget by the passage of Prop 30 and, in some part, Prop 39 (recouping monies from corporations which could no longer choose their own method of taxation).  This means that, from the proposed 2013-14 budget, sent to the Legislature in January, all the way through the process to the budget just signed in June, the schools, including higher education, did much better than they had in previous years.  

The poor, alas, did not.

It All Begins in January
 
In January, as he does in the first month of every year, the Governor sent his first formal draft of the proposed 2013-14 budget to the Legislature. The general description, which, for the last several years, had begun with the term, "budget problem," began this year, tellingly, with the term "budget proposal".  It was a balanced budget, totaling $99.3 billion dollars in General Fund revenues and other available resources and $97.7 billion in General Fund expenditures. The 2012-13 year (which is still ongoing when the Governor presents his budget), was expected to end with a very narrow reserve of $167 million, but, as a result of deep spending reductions, ended up essentially balanced.
 
The 2013-14 budget proposed a reserve of $1 billion, with overall spending growth from the previous year of 5%, mostly because of increased spending in education and healthcare.  As a share of the state's economy, 2012-13 spending was the lowest since 1972-73.  Budget spending hit a peak of $101.3 billion in 2007-08.
 
"Pass Prop 30 Or I'll Shoot Your Schools" 

In November of 2012, under the very real threat that additional billions would be lost to California's public schools, the voters passed a temporary tax measure, the first in decades. The additional revenue was to come from raising tax rates for personal income tax as well as for California's sales and use tax.  Specifically, personal income taxes were raised on high income taxpayers for seven years, beginning in tax year 2012.  Under prior law, the maximum state marginal personal income tax rate was 9.3 %.  Prop 30 temporarily raises personal income tax rates for higher incomes by creating three new tax brackets with rates above 9.3%: 10.3 on income between 250-300,000, 11.3% on income between 300-500,000 and 12.3 % on income in excess of 500,000.  The sales and use tax rate was increased by 1/4 of 1% for four years.  The schools were not only saved from further cuts, the possibility arose that spending might even be increased.  The question remained, of course, just how would the Governor choose to raise levels of school spending.

Leg Analyst: Rosy Projection, Brown: Not So Rosy     

Although the State's Legislative Analyst projected more, the Governor, wisely deciding that nothing succeeds better than low expectations, decided to stay with a conservative estimate of revenue in his January budget proposal.  California does rely on a broad range of taxes and other revenues, but the combined personal income tax, sales and use taxes, and corporate taxes (to a far lesser extent) comprise over 90% of General Fund.  For 2013-14, the Governor's budget assumed about $61.8 billion (63%) from personal income tax revenue, $23.3 billion (24%) from sales and use taxes and $9.1 billion (9%) from taxes on corporations.  In 2012, although income tax and sales and use taxes had already shown a tiny improvement (less than 1%), the corporate taxes had plunged 10%.  Of course, Prop 39, changing the way in which corporations were taxed, had not yet kicked in, and would account for an increase of about $440 million in 2012-13 and $900 million in 2013-14.

Based on the passage of Prop 30, and moderate economic growth in the state, the Governor's budget projected that personal income tax revenue would grow by 2.5% or an increase of $4.9 billion, and sales and use tax revenue would increase by 1.1% or an increase of about $1.3 billion.

More Money For The Kids? Just Not At Home.....

There were no additional reductions in the new budget, but that was not necessarily good news for those who rely on any kind of government program such as Welfare to Work, In Home Support Services, or a myriad of social services.  Having suffered deep cuts in the past years, poor families got no relief from the Governor's proposed budget.  He did, however, add back a bit of money for K-12, Community Colleges and higher education, just as he promised while campaigning for Prop 30.

The budget for K-12 education was increased by 7.2%, from $38 billion to about $41 billion. Higher education got a 13.6% bump, from $9.7 billion to more than $11 billion.  Health and Human Services did show an increase in the bottom line of expenditures, from $27 billion to $28 billion, but it was all in the area needed to be increased due to the roll-out of the Affordable Care Act (which some out there call Obamacare).  As you will see in the next essay, social services stayed frozen at the lowest historical levels.

And About Those Credit Cards Arnold Forgot To Tear Up

Although we all heard (several times, thanks to the echo-journalism syndrome) that the "Governator" was "tearing up the credit cards", the reality was quite different.  Over the Schwarzenegger years, a "Wall of Debt" arose, with budgets accumulating more and more deficit.  Gov. Brown attempts, in his January budget proposal, to tear down some of the "wall", which is comprised of a toxic combination of debts, deferrals, and heavy borrowing from special funds, which are those paid specifically for use in dedicated programs, like recycling bottles or tires.  By the end of 2010-11, the debt had grown to about $35 billion. It was projected to drop to "only" $28 billion by the end of the 2012-13 budget cycle.  Because the temporary taxes passed in Prop 30 don't last forever, the Governor has indicated he hopes to pay off the debt by the time of expiration of the temporary taxes.  This means, of course, that a chunk of the new revenue will have to be used for these purposes each year.  The proposed 2013-14 budget includes $4.2 billion in repayment of debt.

Over the years, budgets had adopted the fiction of "deferrals" in K-12 and community college Prop 98 funding, "borrowing" against a future repayment, which never came.  However, because these monies really were required to be used to fund education, they were kept on the books as a debt to education, which must be payed off.  In the new budget, because of the moderately rosy revenue projections, no additional "deferrals" were projected for Prop 98 and other education payments, and, indeed, there existed the possibility of a modest payoff.
Comments